Theory: Babies from This Game are The Bros In BIS Onward

Remind me of that split timeline theory i had, basically there is one timeline where the bros go back and create a new set of events and another one where they don't which create two timelines, like:

Original timeline = The baby bros manage to defeat the shroobs on their own > SSS > PiT (present) > PJ (DT events doesn't seem to happen)

Altered = The baby bros recieve help to defeat the shroobs > Alternate SSS where they don't meet Fawful > BiS > DT.


Frozen Elder Shroob Princess is from original timeline and she hoped to the alternate one.

BiS Fawful is from the alternate one, he defected from Cackletta earlier and thus did not fought the bros until BiS.

Shopkeeper Fawful is still alive in the original one but idk what he is doing.

So is Antasma (they didn't come to Pi'illo island there, so he should be still sealed away)

The baby were sent back to there time, so that doesn't seem likely.

But the storyline of SSS isn't even possible without those characters.

False Poople said that Mario and Luigi remind him certain stache fools that ruin is earlier plans. Seem like he does know them just not exactly figure them out. As for Kylie, that was long ago and she I would say that memories of the old days can become clouded. Mario and Luigi seem to reconise them. Not so sure for Fawful, as they never seen him in BiS but Starlow did all of the talking any way so I guess we wouldn't. Along with Fawful announcing himself as soon as Bowser encounter (second time) himself so no reason for them to talk about who he is.

Can ya supply a pic of the frozen Elder Shroom? I don't think I see her there (or I don't remember her) I think her sister as though.

The game doesn't really tell how time travel works so it's up in teh air if what they did is intend ot they unintentionally created a split.

She's seen in the back during the battle as well. Much clearer.

I see didn't know, how indeed. There might be a backstory/plot twist in the works. Since Alpha Dream seem to be showing of the Shroobs, maybe they too will have second coming much like Fawful.

For what? Fewful was underplay in SS and Cackletta stole the show. Seem like Fawful have intentionally given the forgotten treatment as he was just working on someone greater (As far as we knew). Sure he had his moments but otherwise not much they could really say on him. That's my theory anyway.