Your sense of humor is exactly like that found in Kid Icarus Uprising, so you will love it. It is a comedy game more than anything, with tons of 4th wall breaking and goofy jokes and puns.
Kid Icarus: Uprising will take less time to beat I am sure. It is a good length, but not super long. It does have tons of stuff to do after you beat, so replay value is high.
I'm so playing Kid Icarus today! I feel hyped because you are going to play it soon!
Once you beat a level you can always go back to it, so when you beat the game you can go and play your favorite levels again! Including Reset Bomb Forest and Moon Base for me!